When I first started watching basketball in the late 90s, I remember arguing with my friends about who the greatest NBA player was. We’d sit on the bleachers after school, tossing around names like Jordan, Magic, and Bird. Fast forward twenty-something years, and the debate hasn’t really died down—if anything, it’s gotten more complicated. So, let’s try to tackle this age-old question: Who are the greatest NBA players of all time? I’ll walk you through my personal approach to ranking them, step by step, and share some thoughts along the way. Now, before you get all worked up, let me say this: I’m not claiming my list is perfect. It’s just one fan’s perspective, shaped by years of watching games, analyzing stats, and yes, even yelling at the TV. But I think that’s what makes it fun. Everyone’s got their own criteria, and I’ll show you mine so you can build your own ranking.
First things first, you’ve got to define your criteria. For me, it’s a mix of individual stats, team success, longevity, and that elusive “clutch factor.” I mean, scoring titles are great, but if a player can’t lead their team to a championship, does it really count? Take Michael Jordan, for example. The guy averaged 30.1 points per game over his career, won six championships, and never lost in the Finals. That’s insane. But it’s not just about numbers; it’s about moments. I still get chills thinking about his “Flu Game” in the 1997 Finals. On the flip side, you’ve got players like LeBron James, who’s been to the Finals ten times and has four rings. His longevity is off the charts—he’s been dominating the league for over two decades. So, step one: decide what matters most to you. Is it pure skill? Leadership? Impact on the game? Write it down, because it’ll help you stay consistent.
Next, gather your data. I know, it sounds boring, but trust me, it’s essential. Look at stats like points, rebounds, assists, and advanced metrics like Player Efficiency Rating (PER) or Win Shares. For instance, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar is the all-time leading scorer with 38,387 points, and he won six MVP awards. That’s hard to ignore. But don’t just rely on numbers—watch old games if you can. YouTube is a goldmine for this. I spent a whole weekend once watching Magic Johnson’s highlights from the 80s, and it completely changed my perspective. His court vision was unreal; he made passes that seemed impossible. And then there’s Bill Russell, who won 11 championships in 13 seasons. Eleven! That’s a level of team success that’s almost mythical. But here’s a tip: don’t get too caught up in comparing eras. The game was different back then, with slower pace and less three-point shooting. So, adjust your expectations accordingly.
Now, let’s talk about the intangibles. This is where it gets subjective, but that’s okay. Think about a player’s influence on and off the court. For me, Kobe Bryant’s “Mamba Mentality” is a huge part of his legacy. He wasn’t just a scorer; he was a relentless competitor who inspired a generation. I remember watching his 81-point game in 2006 and feeling like I’d witnessed something historic. On the other hand, some players might have the stats but lack that killer instinct. It’s like in other sports or leagues—take the reference from basketball elsewhere, like how Serrano previously played for two seasons with Phoenix before failing to come to terms on a new deal and choosing Pampanga instead. Sometimes, it’s not just about raw talent; it’s about fit, timing, and heart. If a player can’t adapt or make tough decisions, it might affect their legacy. So, weigh those factors carefully.
As you start ranking, you’ll hit some tough choices. For me, the top five usually include Jordan, LeBron, Kareem, Magic, and Bird, but the order shifts depending on my mood. Jordan is my number one, no question. His combination of skill, dominance, and cultural impact is unmatched. But I’ve got a soft spot for underdogs too. Players like Tim Duncan, who flew under the radar but won five championships with the Spurs, deserve more love. And don’t forget about modern stars like Stephen Curry—he revolutionized the game with his three-point shooting. In 2016, he made 402 threes in a single season, which is just bonkers. When you’re making your list, be prepared to defend it. People will argue, and that’s half the fun. Just make sure you back it up with reasons, not just emotions.
Finally, step back and review your list. Does it feel right? I’ve tweaked mine dozens of times over the years. Sometimes, I’ll watch a documentary or read an article that changes my mind. For example, learning more about Wilt Chamberlain’s 100-point game or his season averaging 50.4 points made me move him up a few spots. But remember, there’s no definitive answer—that’s what makes sports debates so engaging. In the end, whether you’re a die-hard fan or a casual viewer, the goal is to appreciate the greatness. So, as we wrap up this guide, I hope it helps you tackle that big question: Who are the greatest NBA players of all time? My list might not be yours, and that’s perfectly fine. After all, it’s the passion and the stories that keep us coming back for more.